Need some opinions about the Gmoccapy GUI

Two points I would like to hear your opinion about.
1. Currently gmoccapy shows the current velocity in the Rapid Override frame (1). I think the velocity does not really fit there. In earlier gmoccapy versions there was an override for maximum velocity, so that was correct.It is not really consistent with the other displays and a user could expect kind of a more static value like maximum_machine_velocity * override_factor.
I think we have three options here:

• 1.1 Re-arrange the GUI that the current velocity gets its own frame (2). Disadvantage: looks a bit ugly and inconsistent.
• 1.2 Change the value of (1) to maximum_machine_velocity * override_factor. But I think the current velocity is more useful that this value)
• 1.3 Leave it as it is because it looks good this way and is clear enough

What do you think about that?


2. The spindle off button in spindle-off-state is currently yellow. Could be changed to red to be more consistent with usual operator panels like that e.g.:

Hello Hans, 

1.) I personally would say "leave as is". Never really bothered me, but would be fine either way. 

2.) I would agree "red" is better but yellow works for me here as well. 

Since we are talking about "opinions", I thought I would ask about the +/- buttons and the jog and override sliders:

It would be great to make the sliders touchable (drag and move) to quickly adjust the settings. I hardly never use the +/- buttons, as they are too slow to adjust the setting. 

I created a couple of custom buttons for jogging. Turtle might work here as well but it gives only 2 options. 
 


Next to the override frames, I added custom buttons for rapid override / feed override. Again, same here: +/- is way to slow for making adjustment on the fly. 
 

I understand that space might be limited on 15" screens, but on 17"+ touch I really like those buttons and use them frequently. 

Maybe food for thought. 

Hallo Hans,

I would leave the speed indication as it is, I completely agree with you opinieon, that it is not placed perfect, but I do not like the "additional splitting" of the screen Design to get the vel in a separate frame.

According to the spindle button, I made it yellow in first step, as all active buttons has been yellow in the first decade of developing gmoccapy.
Now I agree, that red would be better.

Norbert

Hello Hans,

I wish this:
 
1) Actual velocity
2) maximum_machine_velocity * override_factor
3) actual_feed_velocity * override_factor

---

I don't like the red spindle button. To me, red means a mistake or danger. If you are going to use the color red for normal operation, you cannot escalate any warnings with the color red.

---

I wish another EMBED_TAB_LOCATION 8:
 
Sometime in the future, I would like to build a machine where all drivers will be connected to Modbus and I will display the load of all axes, just like adult machines have.
 

I can't recall off the top of my head but there is something odd about the spindle button, maybe it's because my machine is on 2.8....

I think that when the spindle is on, the button goes grey. I always find that odd when I go to stop the spindle that the buttons are grey.

Just talking about point 2 now.

I thought about having the icons without background and let CSS define the background. So everyone can use a custom css file. But that inferferes with the symbolic icons from other icon themes. So maybe it's not a good idea.

Without background


With background

zz912 wrote:

I don't like the red spindle button. To me, red means a mistake or danger. If you are going to use the color red for normal operation, you cannot escalate any warnings with the color red.

That was also my concern.
Maybe something like this?

zz912 wrote:

I wish another EMBED_TAB_LOCATION 8:
Sometime in the future, I would like to build a machine where all drivers will be connected to Modbus and I will display the load of all axes, just like adult machines have.

That's a good idea and easy to add.

blazini36 wrote:

I can't recall off the top of my head but there is something odd about the spindle button, maybe it's because my machine is on 2.8....

I think that when the spindle is on, the button goes grey. I always find that odd when I go to stop the spindle that the buttons are grey.

Yeah but it complies with the design that buttons with active states are highlighted.

Do you have something like this in mind?



I still tend to


You always can use a custom theme with those buttons swapped or modified.

First option is defenetely my favorite, Wow I like that one!
Modern and easy to interprate!

Norbert

Which one? I posted 5 images...

First one +1

Aciera wrote:

First one +1

Same here - which one?