using old pc advice
09 Dec 2015 03:01 #66662
by 64dodge
using old pc advice was created by 64dodge
I have 6 towers with tyan s1867 thunder 2500 mobos with 3dlabs oxygen gvx210 video cards and dual 850 PIII (less memory) in my computer junk pile. These were high end ProE workstations many years ago where I worked. Has anyone tried using these for Linuxcnc. I know I would be better off getting a newer system but this would be for a dedicated machine. Just wondering if it would be worthwhile to get registered memory and try. They accept up to 8gb.
Thanks
Tim
Thanks
Tim
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
09 Dec 2015 09:09 - 09 Dec 2015 10:45 #66669
by ArcEye
Replied by ArcEye on topic using old pc advice
The best (and only) way to know, is to test them.
Initially just run the live CD, from a plug in USB DVD if necessary.
(if no USB and no CD-ROM, perhaps see if the local museum wants them and move on
)
Run the latency-test, let things settle to rule out slow disc access etc, reset the counters and see what results you get.
Newer is not necessarily better with rtai, I get far better latency on a P4 with a uni-processor kernel than I can on anything newer since.
Regards memory, not sure if the Debian kernel is now actually pae now, wasn't to start with, but 4GB is probably the max you would possibly need.
Try it with what you have first, the last PIII I tried was painfully slow to work with and having more than one core or processor is not actually an advantage latency wise, quite the reverse.
Give it a go
regards
Initially just run the live CD, from a plug in USB DVD if necessary.
(if no USB and no CD-ROM, perhaps see if the local museum wants them and move on
![B) B)](/media/kunena/emoticons/cool.png)
Run the latency-test, let things settle to rule out slow disc access etc, reset the counters and see what results you get.
Newer is not necessarily better with rtai, I get far better latency on a P4 with a uni-processor kernel than I can on anything newer since.
Regards memory, not sure if the Debian kernel is now actually pae now, wasn't to start with, but 4GB is probably the max you would possibly need.
Try it with what you have first, the last PIII I tried was painfully slow to work with and having more than one core or processor is not actually an advantage latency wise, quite the reverse.
Give it a go
regards
Last edit: 09 Dec 2015 10:45 by ArcEye.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
09 Dec 2015 12:11 #66676
by BigJohnT
Replied by BigJohnT on topic using old pc advice
uname -r returns 3.4-9rtai-686-pae on my LinuxMint 2.7.3 machine.
If you have a CD drive try the Ubuntu 10.04 LiveCD.
JT
If you have a CD drive try the Ubuntu 10.04 LiveCD.
JT
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
09 Dec 2015 23:24 #66707
by 64dodge
Replied by 64dodge on topic using old pc advice
They all have cd & pci usb cards. Ive tried 8-10 p4 and athlon boards from 1-2.4 ghz out of my large stash of crappy old pcs all with bad latency.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
10 Dec 2015 06:53 - 11 Dec 2015 15:48 #66716
by ArcEye
You need to run the 8.04 distro or use a home brew UP kernel as I did on P4s, 10.04 tends to produce rubbish latency.
The PIIIs will definitely need 8.04
regards
Replied by ArcEye on topic using old pc advice
They all have cd & pci usb cards. Ive tried 8-10 p4 and athlon boards from 1-2.4 ghz out of my large stash of crappy old pcs all with bad latency.
You need to run the 8.04 distro or use a home brew UP kernel as I did on P4s, 10.04 tends to produce rubbish latency.
The PIIIs will definitely need 8.04
regards
Last edit: 11 Dec 2015 15:48 by ArcEye.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
10 Dec 2015 23:12 #66773
by 64dodge
Replied by 64dodge on topic using old pc advice
Ya I have been using 10.04 the computers seem to run the operating system all right. I didnt know each one would give different latency that seems strange. 10.04 Is what i am using now while typing on a asus k7vt mobo 1 gig amd 768 mb memory. I have 8 & 6 with emc2 downloaded just need to burn them to cd. Bought 4x512 mb reg memory off ebay for $9.95 should get here monday i hope.
Thanks for the replies
Tim
Thanks for the replies
Tim
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tommylight
-
- Away
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 18500
- Thank you received: 6176
10 Dec 2015 23:48 #66776
by tommylight
Replied by tommylight on topic using old pc advice
8.04 is usable with 512Mb, 10.04 at least 1Gb, debian wheezy hybrid iso is quite usable on a geode amd processor at 1Ghz with 512Mb of ram.
From experience i would use debian on your systems without a doubt, as for latency, try it with both processors and then remove one and test again.
Again from experience if they have an intel chipset, you are good to go, anything else and it's a hit and miss, and if by any chance they have ALI or OLI chipsets, proceed as ArcEye suggested.
Again, disable the serial ports and on some mother boards the sound card and modem, they can be very bad for latency on those systems.
Regards,
Tom
From experience i would use debian on your systems without a doubt, as for latency, try it with both processors and then remove one and test again.
Again from experience if they have an intel chipset, you are good to go, anything else and it's a hit and miss, and if by any chance they have ALI or OLI chipsets, proceed as ArcEye suggested.
Again, disable the serial ports and on some mother boards the sound card and modem, they can be very bad for latency on those systems.
Regards,
Tom
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
11 Dec 2015 04:22 #66790
by 64dodge
Replied by 64dodge on topic using old pc advice
I just tried 8.04 and man what a difference. Exact same computer with no bios adjustments (athlon xp 1800+) and latency was a quarter of what 10.04 was. How can this be?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
11 Dec 2015 05:25 #66792
by 64dodge
Replied by 64dodge on topic using old pc advice
forum.linuxcnc.org/forum/18-computer/191...me-latency-solutions
I had read this before and didnt understand about how the different kernels work and smp but now I can see the light a little.
I had read this before and didnt understand about how the different kernels work and smp but now I can see the light a little.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
11 Dec 2015 15:50 #66827
by ArcEye
Glad you found the FAQ useful.
It makes a hell of a difference with the older uni-processor machines.
regards
Replied by ArcEye on topic using old pc advice
forum.linuxcnc.org/forum/18-computer/191...me-latency-solutions
I had read this before and didnt understand about how the different kernels work and smp but now I can see the light a little.
Glad you found the FAQ useful.
It makes a hell of a difference with the older uni-processor machines.
regards
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.085 seconds