Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
- MacKaye
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
24 Nov 2024 18:34 #315185
by MacKaye
Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion was created by MacKaye
Hi,
i have a rather ambitious project on my hand. I need to convert my Weiler DZ26 as of today my old 810T control finally went the way of the dodo.
I´ve put so much time and effort into keeping that old thing running and making it jump through hoops via CAD/CAM and my own postprocessor, but enough is enough.
My plan is to get basic turning functionality working and look into millturn operation later.
In general the machine is a dynamic (20m/min), high acceleration monster(for its time), with a super quick Sauter 12 station toolchanger (all stations driven).
I plan on using the original Siemens drives and motors. Both spindles need to run in high- or low drive modes for A-axis operation and toolchanging modes. Both spindles have two encoders for high rpm operation and low rpm positioning. The Control need to switch a number of accessories like coolant pump, self oiler, solenoids for mode switch of the tool changer and so on...
I will start with a kind of allright office PC to get it up and running and plan on switching to a proper industrial PC later on.
From what i have read over the years if you have a dynamic machine, your better served with PCIE based mesa boards.
My current plan is getting myself a 6i25 and a 7i77 breakout board. Should have enough I/O for my needs and PCIE should keep it rather real time.
Do you have any suggestions and/or questions? I will document my progress over here and definetly need some help every once in a while.
What would be your recommended GUI for a machine like that? I have next to no experience in LinuxCNC, but are pretty decent in all kinds of Siemens controls.
Best,
Lukas
i have a rather ambitious project on my hand. I need to convert my Weiler DZ26 as of today my old 810T control finally went the way of the dodo.
I´ve put so much time and effort into keeping that old thing running and making it jump through hoops via CAD/CAM and my own postprocessor, but enough is enough.
My plan is to get basic turning functionality working and look into millturn operation later.
In general the machine is a dynamic (20m/min), high acceleration monster(for its time), with a super quick Sauter 12 station toolchanger (all stations driven).
I plan on using the original Siemens drives and motors. Both spindles need to run in high- or low drive modes for A-axis operation and toolchanging modes. Both spindles have two encoders for high rpm operation and low rpm positioning. The Control need to switch a number of accessories like coolant pump, self oiler, solenoids for mode switch of the tool changer and so on...
I will start with a kind of allright office PC to get it up and running and plan on switching to a proper industrial PC later on.
From what i have read over the years if you have a dynamic machine, your better served with PCIE based mesa boards.
My current plan is getting myself a 6i25 and a 7i77 breakout board. Should have enough I/O for my needs and PCIE should keep it rather real time.
Do you have any suggestions and/or questions? I will document my progress over here and definetly need some help every once in a while.
What would be your recommended GUI for a machine like that? I have next to no experience in LinuxCNC, but are pretty decent in all kinds of Siemens controls.
Best,
Lukas
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tommylight
- Away
- Moderator
Less
More
- Posts: 19409
- Thank you received: 6507
24 Nov 2024 20:23 #315189
by tommylight
Replied by tommylight on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
In this order:
7i97T single board with everything
7i92TM + 7i77 the first plugs into the second so no cables needed.
Both sets are Ethernet, not PCI-E, so they can be placed anywhere on the machine and need a single lan cable to the PC.
7i97T single board with everything
7i92TM + 7i77 the first plugs into the second so no cables needed.
Both sets are Ethernet, not PCI-E, so they can be placed anywhere on the machine and need a single lan cable to the PC.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- MacKaye
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
25 Nov 2024 07:16 #315221
by MacKaye
Replied by MacKaye on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
Thank your for your suggestions. Doesn´t using Ethernet compromise system performance? If have read that using PCIE offers the higher performance advantage, or is it neglible? An ethernet card would be easier during setup, but my goal is to have everything inside the original spacious cabinet anyways.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- RotarySMP
- Offline
- Platinum Member
Less
More
- Posts: 1453
- Thank you received: 526
25 Nov 2024 09:59 #315226
by RotarySMP
Replied by RotarySMP on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
It is unlikely that the 7i77 (or 7i97) will have enough I/O for such a machine. You will probably end up with a 7i84 to expand that.
A 7i73 for the user module also greatly simplifies the wirning between the cabinet and the control head.
A 7i73 for the user module also greatly simplifies the wirning between the cabinet and the control head.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- MacKaye
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
25 Nov 2024 12:37 #315233
by MacKaye
Replied by MacKaye on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
Ah, i´ve been watching your stuff for a while to get a sense for what i am getting into, nice content!
You are using a pretty elaborate control interface on your Schaublin. I am not sure if i want to go down that route though. All i need is some jogging control to set offsets, tool measurements, start stop and feed override. My idea is using a USB pendant, a footswitch for my chuck and everything else on a touchscreen.
For years i have done nothing but adjust tool offsets on the control itself, everything else is straight from cam. And for jogging a pendant doesn´t need to be real time control via the FPGA in my mind.
Or am i totally wrong about LinuxCNCs control interface?
You are using a pretty elaborate control interface on your Schaublin. I am not sure if i want to go down that route though. All i need is some jogging control to set offsets, tool measurements, start stop and feed override. My idea is using a USB pendant, a footswitch for my chuck and everything else on a touchscreen.
For years i have done nothing but adjust tool offsets on the control itself, everything else is straight from cam. And for jogging a pendant doesn´t need to be real time control via the FPGA in my mind.
Or am i totally wrong about LinuxCNCs control interface?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tommylight
- Away
- Moderator
Less
More
- Posts: 19409
- Thank you received: 6507
25 Nov 2024 12:57 #315234
by tommylight
Replied by tommylight on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
Where did you read about Ethernet compromising performance?
Mesa has no such issues, they can do easily MHz range pulses, KHz servo rates (i have tested at 4 KHz 5i25, 6i25 and 7i92).
I have several industrial machines using Mesa, in use daily for many years. Retrofit and build logs are on this forum and youtube, but my videos are cr@p compared to RotarySMP's.
Mesa has no such issues, they can do easily MHz range pulses, KHz servo rates (i have tested at 4 KHz 5i25, 6i25 and 7i92).
I have several industrial machines using Mesa, in use daily for many years. Retrofit and build logs are on this forum and youtube, but my videos are cr@p compared to RotarySMP's.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- MacKaye
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
25 Nov 2024 16:15 #315239
by MacKaye
Replied by MacKaye on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
There seems to be a general dislike for PCI-E cards?
In theory i should be less issues in communication between PC and card and almost no jitter/latency between both.
In theory i should be less issues in communication between PC and card and almost no jitter/latency between both.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- tommylight
- Away
- Moderator
Less
More
- Posts: 19409
- Thank you received: 6507
25 Nov 2024 17:41 #315242
by tommylight
Replied by tommylight on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
The only ones disliking it are persons who do not bother to read the manual and move jumpers around with no idea of what and how that effects the card.
Probelem is, those persons make the most noise.
Again, i have in use over 70 or 80 (probably more) of Mesa boards, be it PCI or PCI-E or Ethernet, never had a single issue, ever, for over 10 years (probably more), all those machines are in use daily in production, not hobby use.
And i have no affiliations with Mesa, i have to pay at least twice the listed price to get them, and it is bloody worth it as i set them once and can sleep at ease knowing they will not fail, ever.
By now it has gotten to the point where if and when any fail, i will have a party.
Probelem is, those persons make the most noise.
Again, i have in use over 70 or 80 (probably more) of Mesa boards, be it PCI or PCI-E or Ethernet, never had a single issue, ever, for over 10 years (probably more), all those machines are in use daily in production, not hobby use.
And i have no affiliations with Mesa, i have to pay at least twice the listed price to get them, and it is bloody worth it as i set them once and can sleep at ease knowing they will not fail, ever.
By now it has gotten to the point where if and when any fail, i will have a party.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- RotarySMP
- Offline
- Platinum Member
Less
More
- Posts: 1453
- Thank you received: 526
26 Nov 2024 11:26 #315287
by RotarySMP
Replied by RotarySMP on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
I used the 5i25 +7i77+7i84 on my Maho, as the Ethernet cards were not yet available. Used the 7i95 on my mini lathe, and a 7i92+7i83+7i84+7i85+7i73 on the Schaublin.
As Tommy said, forget performance differences between PCI and Ethernet cards, that wont be an issue.
I hate jogging on a touch screen. You are looking at the part, probe, whatever and reaching to touch a none tactile feedback peice of glass with a greasy finger, trying to tap through pulse by pulse. Same with feed hold, cycle start, coolant start etc. It is a personal choice.
As Tommy said, forget performance differences between PCI and Ethernet cards, that wont be an issue.
I hate jogging on a touch screen. You are looking at the part, probe, whatever and reaching to touch a none tactile feedback peice of glass with a greasy finger, trying to tap through pulse by pulse. Same with feed hold, cycle start, coolant start etc. It is a personal choice.
The following user(s) said Thank You: tommylight
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- MacKaye
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 6
- Thank you received: 0
14 Dec 2024 14:32 #316649
by MacKaye
Replied by MacKaye on topic Weiler DZ26 Millturn Conversion
Got a 6i25 and 7i77d in front of me and i am ready get things started.
I got myself an old office PC to get things going and will migrate to a DIN Rail PC with a proper touchscreen once everything's running.
A few questions straight after studying the 7i77 manual and ripping out lots of cables from the machine.
Can i sink solenoid power straight to the 7i77? Does it have some flyback diodes integrated? Is there a max current rating for those sinking inputs? Original Siemens IO cards had direct connection to all solenoids.
Best,
Lukas
I got myself an old office PC to get things going and will migrate to a DIN Rail PC with a proper touchscreen once everything's running.
A few questions straight after studying the 7i77 manual and ripping out lots of cables from the machine.
Can i sink solenoid power straight to the 7i77? Does it have some flyback diodes integrated? Is there a max current rating for those sinking inputs? Original Siemens IO cards had direct connection to all solenoids.
Best,
Lukas
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: piasdom
Time to create page: 0.164 seconds