may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!!
- brmachineshop
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 9
- Thank you received: 0
31 Jan 2012 00:01 #17285
by brmachineshop
may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!! was created by brmachineshop
My machine went down TEN MONTHS AGO. I went with mach 3 for my pc conversion. Bought dugong drives. Cnc4pc breakout boards, encoders. Took forever to figure out the wiring because of poor documentation. Finally had it running correct distance one axis at a time but when I ran two at a time it way overtravelled and didn't show any encoder error message. Pc hard drive crashed. Now I have a different pc but I doubt it will fix the overtravel issue. Hindsight stinks.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
31 Jan 2012 10:04 #17294
by andypugh
Replied by andypugh on topic Re:may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!!
brmachineshop wrote:
What annoys me personally about your situation is that I warned you it would take several months, and the Mach3 fans on the 'Zone said it could be done in a couple of weeks, and I suspect that was partly why you chose Mach3 over LinuxCNC (we have changed name in the meantime)
It's very odd that you got overtravel running two axes, though. I wonder if there is a wiring error giving cross-talk between the step lines so that both drives see both sets of steps?
Despite the tendency of Mach3 fans to under-state the difficulty of the task, Mach should be perfectly capable of running your machine.
My machine went down TEN MONTHS AGO. I went with mach 3 for my pc conversion.
...
Hindsight stinks.
What annoys me personally about your situation is that I warned you it would take several months, and the Mach3 fans on the 'Zone said it could be done in a couple of weeks, and I suspect that was partly why you chose Mach3 over LinuxCNC (we have changed name in the meantime)
It's very odd that you got overtravel running two axes, though. I wonder if there is a wiring error giving cross-talk between the step lines so that both drives see both sets of steps?
Despite the tendency of Mach3 fans to under-state the difficulty of the task, Mach should be perfectly capable of running your machine.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
31 Jan 2012 12:53 - 31 Jan 2012 12:54 #17297
by BigJohnT
Replied by BigJohnT on topic Re:may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!!
I had to google dugong to see what it is... I'm guessing something like a Gecko 320x drive. Just reading the dugong manual and boy is it picky about the power supply.
So what are your plans now?
John
So what are your plans now?
John
Last edit: 31 Jan 2012 12:54 by BigJohnT.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- brmachineshop
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 9
- Thank you received: 0
31 Jan 2012 16:05 #17299
by brmachineshop
Replied by brmachineshop on topic Re:may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!!
My apologies andy. My plans for this project is to keep fighting with it. Lol. My next project may go a different direction.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
31 Jan 2012 16:18 - 31 Jan 2012 16:18 #17300
by PCW
Replied by PCW on topic Re:may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!!
Like Andy says this really sounds like a wiring error in the step/dir signals.
Perhaps a missing ground between the PC/breakout and one or more of the drives.
I would try again by jogging each axis carefully and checking that the other axis do not move.
Perhaps a missing ground between the PC/breakout and one or more of the drives.
I would try again by jogging each axis carefully and checking that the other axis do not move.
Last edit: 31 Jan 2012 16:18 by PCW. Reason: sp
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- dangercraft
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 84
- Thank you received: 0
09 Aug 2012 15:58 - 09 Aug 2012 16:00 #23000
by dangercraft
Replied by dangercraft on topic Re:may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!!
What kind of cabling are you using for your signalling? Is it twisted pair? Shielded? Are you sending the signals from multiple joints through a shared cable? I would suggest investing in a simple usb scope and reading whats coming out of the other end of the cables. Anytime you (or I or anyone else )are working on electronics without some kind of signal visualization (even a cheap usb PC o-scope is more than enough 99% of the time) you are working by making stabs in the dark. Its kind of like watching those discovery channel shows with the orangutangs solving problems by poking holes with twigs.
Taking your problem apart purely from the limited description:
One joint works by itself.
Does the other joint also work by itself?
When both joints run together does one or two joints over-run? If both over-run, do they over-run by the same amount? This would be a gimmie for cable pair cross talk. (Cheap cables? Bad ground and retro feed? Is the cable shield grounded properly?)
This is probably a very simple problem, its just a question of going through the usual suspects first and then moving to the more complicated probable causes.
Frank
Taking your problem apart purely from the limited description:
One joint works by itself.
Does the other joint also work by itself?
When both joints run together does one or two joints over-run? If both over-run, do they over-run by the same amount? This would be a gimmie for cable pair cross talk. (Cheap cables? Bad ground and retro feed? Is the cable shield grounded properly?)
This is probably a very simple problem, its just a question of going through the usual suspects first and then moving to the more complicated probable causes.
Frank
Last edit: 09 Aug 2012 16:00 by dangercraft.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
13 Aug 2012 15:38 #23090
by doug6949
Replied by doug6949 on topic Re:may have made the wrong choice @#$%%$###!!!
dangercraft wrote:This is probably a very simple problem, its just a question of going through the usual suspects first and then moving to the more complicated probable causes.Frank[/quote]
The problem turned out to be incompatibility between the CNC4PC board and the Dugong HDBB board, which Brad had connected in series. Once he removed the CNC4PC board the problem went away. Last time I talked to him he was making good parts.
Doug
The problem turned out to be incompatibility between the CNC4PC board and the Dugong HDBB board, which Brad had connected in series. Once he removed the CNC4PC board the problem went away. Last time I talked to him he was making good parts.
Doug
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: piasdom
Time to create page: 0.111 seconds