How good stepper motors with feedback?
11 Apr 2016 11:32 #73094
by aleksamc
How good stepper motors with feedback? was created by aleksamc
Hi all.
Currently I use steppers with open loop control and they are loos steps much and can work only very slowly.
Can I buy driver for closed loop stepper and connect it with encoders. Steppers are for example ES-D Series of leadshine? Can this driver or other similar fix my problem with losing steps?
Currently I use steppers with open loop control and they are loos steps much and can work only very slowly.
Can I buy driver for closed loop stepper and connect it with encoders. Steppers are for example ES-D Series of leadshine? Can this driver or other similar fix my problem with losing steps?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
11 Apr 2016 14:45 #73109
by andypugh
That depends on whether steps are lost in the signal side or the physical side.
A properly-designed system with well-chosen motors, good step-timing and functional electronics should never lose steps. One or more of those things must be wrong.
Replied by andypugh on topic How good stepper motors with feedback?
Can this driver or other similar fix my problem with losing steps?
That depends on whether steps are lost in the signal side or the physical side.
A properly-designed system with well-chosen motors, good step-timing and functional electronics should never lose steps. One or more of those things must be wrong.
The following user(s) said Thank You: aleksamc
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
11 Apr 2016 15:15 #73115
by mariusl
Regards
Marius
www.bluearccnc.com
Replied by mariusl on topic How good stepper motors with feedback?
I concur with Andy. You should look at your max acceleration and max velocity. If those are too high you will get slip. You will not get more performance from the motors if you add closed loop control. You can however increase the stepper supply voltage to as much as 80v. Make sure that you drive can handle that kind of voltage.
This will give good speed performance.
This will give good speed performance.
Regards
Marius
www.bluearccnc.com
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
12 Apr 2016 04:41 #73144
by aleksamc
Replied by aleksamc on topic How good stepper motors with feedback?
The mechanical part is definitely well designed, all parts turns well.
The problem possibly could be in because I have may be little high impulse per sec.
The system starts to slip always in one direction - from the object of processing. I will try today to adjust new settings with higher speads and lower steps per imp.
The problem possibly could be in because I have may be little high impulse per sec.
The system starts to slip always in one direction - from the object of processing. I will try today to adjust new settings with higher speads and lower steps per imp.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
13 Apr 2016 10:35 #73217
by aleksamc
Replied by aleksamc on topic How good stepper motors with feedback?
Really problem was in signal side and Chines drivers.
Don't believe what written on them. Dividing steps was messed completely. Where written 1/8 there is 1/256 and where 1/128 - there 1/5.
After this I tuned system well.
Thanks all for saving me from extra expenses.
Don't believe what written on them. Dividing steps was messed completely. Where written 1/8 there is 1/256 and where 1/128 - there 1/5.
After this I tuned system well.
Thanks all for saving me from extra expenses.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.145 seconds