Should I just suck it up and buy a good stepper driver?

More
04 Mar 2025 18:22 #323168 by langdons
I am repairing a CNC machine at my high school.

It has toroidal trasformer with 3 isolated 28.5VAC windings.

It is a 3 axis XYZ machine with each axis controlled by a 4.6A stepping/synchronous motor.

It is connected to a PC running LinuxCNC via a parallelport and PMDX-122 breakout board.

The machine works, but the original 30-year-old stepper drivers are all totally broken.

I bought some DM860H and DM556 drivers off Ebay and Aliexpress, respectively; they worked, but have no flyback diodes.

I accidentally broke all of them.

I ordered 1 new DM860 from Aliexpress.

Should I just suck it up and buy good, genuine drives for the remaining axes?

All the axes?

I can make a rectifier, if needed.

What brands are good?

I am reluctant to spend like $300 ($435 in Canada, where both the machine and I reside).

Canada's potential future retaliatory tarrifs on USA in response to Trump's potential future tarrifs on Canada might affect stuff too.

The computer works fine, so does everything else, all I need is stepper drivers at this point (I need 1-2 THK LM guides for th Z axis, but that's a problem for future me).

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
04 Mar 2025 18:51 #323169 by PCW
All modern step motor drives have flyback diodes, what they typically do not have is an overvoltage clamp.
This means you must never switch the DC power to the drives anywhere between the power supplies output
capacitor and the drive itself. This means no switches/relays/fuses/circuits breakers in the DC circuit. The
fuse in the  drive itself is just for fire protection, if it blows, the drive was already dead.
The following user(s) said Thank You: tommylight

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • tommylight
  • tommylight's Avatar
  • Away
  • Moderator
  • Moderator
More
04 Mar 2025 19:34 #323175 by tommylight


I bought some DM860H and DM556 drivers off Ebay and Aliexpress, respectively; they worked, but have no flyback diodes.

As PCW mentioned above, they do have flyback diodes for sure, but over voltage will destroy them as soon as powered on, and so will wrong polarity, or worst case, powering them with AC power directly from the transformer, that can happen with a miss wired bridge rectifier.
Was it you that had a blown capacitor in another topic?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
04 Mar 2025 21:40 #323185 by langdons
No blown cap.

Also, one DM860H managed to work fine after the fuse blew.

They really don't have any flyback diodes, I assure you.

And the transistors ain't DMOS either.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
04 Mar 2025 21:41 #323186 by langdons
The DM860H drivers have their own rectifier.

They accept AC.
The following user(s) said Thank You: timo

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
04 Mar 2025 22:05 #323190 by PCW
All standard MOSFETs have inherent "body" diodes which will function as flybacks
though typically Schottky diodes are added to reduce voltage drop and hence power
dissipation.
The following user(s) said Thank You: tommylight

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Mar 2025 00:07 #323206 by unknown
Been reading this for while, I think you need to reassess what you think you know compared to what you actually know.
Usually the stepper drivers are pretty hardy, the ones I have in my mill are about 15 years old and haven't missed a beat.
I've never heard of anyone having to make modifications.
Some of the early TB6600 drivers weren't as reliable as they should have been, no experience with them myself but many reports of them being that way.
So just settle down, do things the recommended way and don't try to modify things that don't require modification. And if you still insist of doing board level mods consult the data sheets for the components that will be affected. I'm sure this would have resolved the issue of "no flyback diodes".
The following user(s) said Thank You: tommylight

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Mar 2025 00:12 #323208 by langdons
Oh.

I thought only DMOS had internal diodes.

Now I know.

Thanks!
The following user(s) said Thank You: tommylight

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • tommylight
  • tommylight's Avatar
  • Away
  • Moderator
  • Moderator
More
05 Mar 2025 02:27 #323211 by tommylight
HEXFET, TrenchFET, Epitaxial FET, .... damn i am getting old and this time i am not blaming it on being 3:15AM right now, there are many more types of MOSFET's, and almost all have flyback diodes, you can spend days sifting through catalogs to find any that does not
That is not the point at all, it is to show you how much we have to refrain here when we reply, ...
Again not the point, ....
The point is, do some reading and checking and rechecking before wiring and powering on stuff.
Take Unknowns advice, take a step back to reassess things.
As for TB6600 i have used the original ones and the smaller "not TB6600 despite being named so" and the "not TB6600" are much better and do not die at random. And can be found cheaper at 12-15$ a piece. Might have issues with DIP switches triggering from vibrations, though.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
05 Mar 2025 05:52 - 05 Mar 2025 06:02 #323229 by timo

Been reading this for while, I think you need to reassess what you think you know compared to what you actually know.
Usually the stepper drivers are pretty hardy, the ones I have in my mill are about 15 years old and haven't missed a beat.
I've never heard of anyone having to make modifications.
Some of the early TB6600 drivers weren't as reliable as they should have been, no experience with them myself but many reports of them being that way.
So just settle down, do things the recommended way and don't try to modify things that don't require modification. And if you still insist of doing board level mods consult the data sheets for the components that will be affected. I'm sure this would have resolved the issue of "no flyback diodes".

 
I bought two 2nd hand machines with stepper system. They were pre configured for 4 axis, so I had some spares to kill. Out of the 8 drivers two or three are still working. (so I would say occasional death happens)
At least one or two I probably finished by creating a short when I was "repairing" the machines long time ago.
My guess is that the drivers were running at their limit for a long time and were a little undersized for the motors. (or can something age inside?)
The last year drivers started quitting service one by one. First by making some humming noises during machine start, then eventually stopped working.
Given the prices of new ones, not worth investigating. (but we are still talking 10-15 years, before failure)
Last edit: 05 Mar 2025 06:02 by timo.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: PCWjmelson
Time to create page: 0.072 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum