Best bet for a low cost HW assisted Linuxcnc engine....

More
2 months 3 weeks ago #348464 by tommylight

@Tommy: What do you mean with "China is running a misinformation campaign?", do you refer to some spam we see occasionally here?
Nope, the naming everything related to cnc as "mach3", so beginners think it only works with Mach3, besides the usb cards that only work with mach3.
The following user(s) said Thank You: timo

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
2 months 3 weeks ago #348470 by 3404gerber

* I have asked on the Remora part of the forum if the RP2040 based system (which sounds great!) is ready for prime time and I have had no responses since posting it a couple of weeks ago.  Is the impression I am left with which is that it is not ready and the enthusiam for it has died out?  
 
I saw your post on the in the Remora forum a week ago. I think that the port to RP2040 is not as developed as other port; one reason is probably that there are only few 3D printer control boards based on this mcu. As Scotta wrote in the post:

scotta post=344968 userid=24854

"This Remora port was a hotel room project when I was travelling for work."

I played a bit with it, mainly because I had some rp2040 around, but never used it to move physical axis. That's the next thing; if you want to interact with real world, a Pico might not be enough. You'll need some buffer and optocouplers. And this is something you get out of the box with the Mesa card. I guess you could also try the PicoCNC board designed for grblHAL and put Remora on it, but it's not that cheap anymore either.

For the RP2040 there's also a component called stepper-ninja that might interest you. But again, you'll not find the maturity of Mesa cards there. Really depends what you plan to do with it.

And if you go with a RPi, yo can also design a HAT for it with some SPI drivers; I designed one with TMC5160 drivers on the top and wrote a LinuxCNC component to send target velocity over SPI; I probably wouldn't use this as is on a CNC mill, but I have a Galvo Laser engraver that is mounted on a 3 axis system, which are connected to that HAT. It's been a year now and never had issue with it, but I only use it more or less an hour per week.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
2 months 3 weeks ago #348493 by Mars
Thanks to everyone for their comments. The overall take away from this is that you want a solution with minimal hassle, go with Mesa and pay accordingly.

Let me ask a related, more targetted question: what is the most solid Remora implementation both in terms of solid operation once configured *and* using HW that is solid and has a reasonable support expectancy. Novusun (sounds iffy), esp32 based? RP2040 (sounds experimental), some kind of 3D printer driver board? Other?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.055 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum