Thanks for that @rodw. your contributions in this forum is a godsend. I am still a newbie, nonetheless plan on contributing as much as i can.
The geometry makes sense, i didn't struggle with that. i always unfolded the pipe in my head. the geometry of the pipe is the same but i guess the g-code produced by the CAM is different.
In option 1, where the pipe is on a chuck its a mere single axis rotation command of -60 degrees, and then a movement along the x-joint for notch.
In option 2, the torch would have to maneuver along the pipe which is both a y-axis, z-axis movement, and also c-axis rotation, then a movement along the x-axis for a notch.
Writing all of this has made me realize it is CAM dependent as you said. so nothing would change but I would need to use the genhexkins for full 6-axis. I'll have a go at it then.