Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as
06 Sep 2020 13:17 #180998
by Dex64
Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as was created by Dex64
Hello
I have in my cnc mesa card 7i77 with servopacks yaskawa sgda-04as.
Now I made pid tuning for XY axis. I have a problem with Z axis. When I
have to change P value higher than 0 then axis move. I compensate it via voltage offset at drive.
Axis stops and when I move down everything is ok but when I move up then axis move by itself. Then when
I back with P value to 0 axis axis work properly in both directions (manual jogging). With P=0 ferror is huge. Do You have some advice for
me? Thank You in advance. Screen in attachments
I have in my cnc mesa card 7i77 with servopacks yaskawa sgda-04as.
Now I made pid tuning for XY axis. I have a problem with Z axis. When I
have to change P value higher than 0 then axis move. I compensate it via voltage offset at drive.
Axis stops and when I move down everything is ok but when I move up then axis move by itself. Then when
I back with P value to 0 axis axis work properly in both directions (manual jogging). With P=0 ferror is huge. Do You have some advice for
me? Thank You in advance. Screen in attachments
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
06 Sep 2020 13:52 #181004
by PCW
Replied by PCW on topic Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as
You must have some P term or you do not have position feedback
Are you sure you have the feedback in the proper direction?
Are you sure you have the feedback in the proper direction?
The following user(s) said Thank You: Dex64
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
06 Sep 2020 17:32 #181045
by Dex64
Replied by Dex64 on topic Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as
Hi
Youre right. I had inverted feedback to this axis. Now it works ok. Thanks a lot.
I have one more question. How can I compensate this peak ferror in axis X and Y?
I attached screens from linux and software from driver.
Youre right. I had inverted feedback to this axis. Now it works ok. Thanks a lot.
I have one more question. How can I compensate this peak ferror in axis X and Y?
I attached screens from linux and software from driver.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
06 Sep 2020 17:37 #181047
by Dex64
Replied by Dex64 on topic Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as
Properly screens here:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
06 Sep 2020 17:38 #181048
by Dex64
Replied by Dex64 on topic Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as
From driver software :
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
06 Sep 2020 17:45 #181051
by Dex64
Replied by Dex64 on topic Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as
Here from driver software:
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
06 Sep 2020 18:04 #181055
by PCW
Replied by PCW on topic Z axis Pid tuning mesa 7i77 & Yaskawa sgda-04as
It looks to me that maybe you have the maximum velocity too high in LinuxCNC
(The PID doesn't have enough headroom to control the velocity when it gets to the slew
point of the motion, you can see the error build up until it starts to slow down again)
Normally you should not go any faster than about the velocity at 9V, so you have 10% headroom
(The PID doesn't have enough headroom to control the velocity when it gets to the slew
point of the motion, you can see the error build up until it starts to slow down again)
Normally you should not go any faster than about the velocity at 9V, so you have 10% headroom
The following user(s) said Thank You: Dex64
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.071 seconds