What i thought was mechanical backlash, is not.
- bevins
-
Topic Author
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 1944
- Thank you received: 337
26 Oct 2017 05:33 - 26 Oct 2017 05:34 #100827
by bevins
What i thought was mechanical backlash, is not. was created by bevins
Hi all,
On one of my machines i have these big ac servos. Y axis only, it has 1/16” play. I can move the axis when the drives are enabled 1/16”. This axis is 1” ballscrew with 1to1 timing belt to motor. When i removed the covers to the timing belt/pulleys, i saw when i move the axis by hand the pully on the servo is moving also. I checked and the pulley is not slipping on the motor.
So my question is, could it be a defective motor? I can turn the pully slightly by movin* the timing belt then i feel it trying to pull back which inassume is lcnc correcting the feedback. I am pretty confimdent this is where i am seeing the slight overruns in the piece i am cutting.
Could this be caused by poor tuning?
Thnaks,
Bob
On one of my machines i have these big ac servos. Y axis only, it has 1/16” play. I can move the axis when the drives are enabled 1/16”. This axis is 1” ballscrew with 1to1 timing belt to motor. When i removed the covers to the timing belt/pulleys, i saw when i move the axis by hand the pully on the servo is moving also. I checked and the pulley is not slipping on the motor.
So my question is, could it be a defective motor? I can turn the pully slightly by movin* the timing belt then i feel it trying to pull back which inassume is lcnc correcting the feedback. I am pretty confimdent this is where i am seeing the slight overruns in the piece i am cutting.
Could this be caused by poor tuning?
Thnaks,
Bob
Last edit: 26 Oct 2017 05:34 by bevins.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- emcPT
-
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 702
- Thank you received: 139
26 Oct 2017 06:21 #100828
by emcPT
Replied by emcPT on topic What i thought was mechanical backlash, is not.
Yes, poor tunning can be the reason, probably because of a low P gain.
If you inspect the following error using halscope during that move that you force you will see the error increasing if the reason is a bad tunning.
If you inspect the following error using halscope during that move that you force you will see the error increasing if the reason is a bad tunning.
The following user(s) said Thank You: bevins
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- bevins
-
Topic Author
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 1944
- Thank you received: 337
27 Oct 2017 15:12 #100885
by bevins
Thanks, I upped the P in the PID and tightened up the belt and it almost disappeared completely. i will work on it more.
Thanks for the tip.
Bob
Replied by bevins on topic What i thought was mechanical backlash, is not.
Yes, poor tunning can be the reason, probably because of a low P gain.
If you inspect the following error using halscope during that move that you force you will see the error increasing if the reason is a bad tunning.
Thanks, I upped the P in the PID and tightened up the belt and it almost disappeared completely. i will work on it more.
Thanks for the tip.
Bob
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.101 seconds