Oscillating stepper motors
- Muz94
- Offline
- Senior Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 79
- Thank you received: 2
31 Oct 2017 21:42 #101086
by Muz94
Oscillating stepper motors was created by Muz94
Hi, i'm having a wierd problem with my z axis motors.
First of all my configuration is the following:
i'm running the latest version of linuxcnc (2.7.11), and i'm controlling the machine with a simple parrallel port BOB.
I have 4 nema 23 motors ( X Y Z Z ) with the 2 Z motors sharing the outputs on the breakout board (i know, it's not ideal, but for a 3d printer prototype, even if well built, it's enough for now), powered by some chinese drivers (something like this www.ebay.it/itm/TB6600-Single-Axis-4A-St...6:g:D2MAAOSw-olZ6LX1)
The problem is the following: considering the fact that i need perfect allignment of the z axis gantry i disabled microstepping on those 2 motors, but now i noticed a strange problem.
(apart from being quite stuttery, but that's normal without microstepping) when running at ~ 220mm/min those 2 motors moves back and forth like crazy, they simply vibrate and rotate in both directions randomly.
It's enough to increase or reduce the speed of 30-50 mm/min and they start working as they should.
I tryed changing the steps settings in the hal file (i found a thread in this forum with some suggested values) but i couldn't see any difference,
Do you know how i can fix this?
Thank you for your attention.
First of all my configuration is the following:
i'm running the latest version of linuxcnc (2.7.11), and i'm controlling the machine with a simple parrallel port BOB.
I have 4 nema 23 motors ( X Y Z Z ) with the 2 Z motors sharing the outputs on the breakout board (i know, it's not ideal, but for a 3d printer prototype, even if well built, it's enough for now), powered by some chinese drivers (something like this www.ebay.it/itm/TB6600-Single-Axis-4A-St...6:g:D2MAAOSw-olZ6LX1)
The problem is the following: considering the fact that i need perfect allignment of the z axis gantry i disabled microstepping on those 2 motors, but now i noticed a strange problem.
(apart from being quite stuttery, but that's normal without microstepping) when running at ~ 220mm/min those 2 motors moves back and forth like crazy, they simply vibrate and rotate in both directions randomly.
It's enough to increase or reduce the speed of 30-50 mm/min and they start working as they should.
I tryed changing the steps settings in the hal file (i found a thread in this forum with some suggested values) but i couldn't see any difference,
Do you know how i can fix this?
Thank you for your attention.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- PCW
-
- Away
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 18501
- Thank you received: 5065
31 Oct 2017 22:02 #101087
by PCW
Replied by PCW on topic Oscillating stepper motors
If you disable microstepping, its very likely that you will have resonance issues
( and crazy back/for motions at certain speeds sounds likely to be caused by resonance )
I would try 1/4 or 1/8 stepping and see if the problem goes away
( and crazy back/for motions at certain speeds sounds likely to be caused by resonance )
I would try 1/4 or 1/8 stepping and see if the problem goes away
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Muz94
- Offline
- Senior Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 79
- Thank you received: 2
31 Oct 2017 22:29 - 31 Oct 2017 22:29 #101088
by Muz94
Replied by Muz94 on topic Oscillating stepper motors
The problem actually disappears already with 1/4 microstepping.
Do you think that using that setup could create problems with a gantry configuration?
I read somewhere that microstepping could lead to misalignment as the motor can skip to the following / previous step.
Do you think that using that setup could create problems with a gantry configuration?
I read somewhere that microstepping could lead to misalignment as the motor can skip to the following / previous step.
Last edit: 31 Oct 2017 22:29 by Muz94.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- andypugh
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
Less
More
- Posts: 23297
- Thank you received: 4938
03 Nov 2017 16:11 #101261
by andypugh
No.
Microstep alignment is not so accurate as full-step alignment, but the errors, even in the worst case, are much less than one full step.
Replied by andypugh on topic Oscillating stepper motors
Do you think that using that setup could create problems with a gantry configuration?
No.
Microstep alignment is not so accurate as full-step alignment, but the errors, even in the worst case, are much less than one full step.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Muz94
- Offline
- Senior Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 79
- Thank you received: 2
03 Nov 2017 16:23 #101263
by Muz94
Replied by Muz94 on topic Oscillating stepper motors
Ok, that's not too bad.
My only concern was that the errors could add up, but thinking better at how stepper works that should not happen (unless they loose steps for eccessive load).
Even if one of the motors jumps at the following step instead of making partial steps, the error should be canceled when the other motor also reaches the end of the full step, shouldn't It?
My only concern was that the errors could add up, but thinking better at how stepper works that should not happen (unless they loose steps for eccessive load).
Even if one of the motors jumps at the following step instead of making partial steps, the error should be canceled when the other motor also reaches the end of the full step, shouldn't It?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Todd Zuercher
-
- Offline
- Platinum Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 4987
- Thank you received: 1455
03 Nov 2017 16:58 #101275
by Todd Zuercher
Replied by Todd Zuercher on topic Oscillating stepper motors
When a step motor losses steps, it loose one full step or more, and it will not self correct. This should not be confused with position inaccuracy of a micro-stepped step motor, Micro-steps will self correct up to the point where the step motor is pushed over the "hill" into the next full step "valley".
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Muz94
- Offline
- Senior Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 79
- Thank you received: 2
03 Nov 2017 18:21 #101285
by Muz94
Replied by Muz94 on topic Oscillating stepper motors
Ok i got it now.
The first time i read about microstepping errors i didn't think at how the motor actually works and i misunderstood it, thinking that it could add up.
I will enable 1/8 microstepping on the z too then.
The first time i read about microstepping errors i didn't think at how the motor actually works and i misunderstood it, thinking that it could add up.
I will enable 1/8 microstepping on the z too then.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.071 seconds