Converting a 7i76e config to 7c81/7i76 pair

cornholio wrote:

I was under the impression that the hm2-rpspi required a entry in the dev folder for spi and the Hal gpio driver was a different beast.
 

hm2-rpspi does not require the SPI  device driver (or GPIO)
but mesaflash does require the SPI device driver

From the info I found, I could be wrong, the mainline kernel doesn’t support device tree overlays, or the mechanism required to get an spi device entry in /dev. It would seem this a patch that the raspbian team applies.
So I’m thinking that until the raspbian team has a kernel for bookworm, the Raspberry Pi will require Bullseye for any board that requires SPI to operate.
Bookworm should, in theory, be fine for Ethernet devices.
Now I could be totally wrong regarding this.

Sebastian has hm2_rpspi running under Debian Bookworm. I succeeded in getting spi-bcm2835 to load on boot but I still can't create the /dev/spi0.0 and /dev/spi0.1 devices on Bookworm. The kernel on Bookworm compiles the devices that would normally be loaded in the device tree as kernel modules. So, I am just trying to find out what piece or pieces are either missing or not loaded.
I just think it would be great to be able to run mesaflash on the 7c81 on Bookworm.

The issue is and if you at this post forum.linuxcnc.org/38-general-linuxcnc-q...pair?start=10#279252
it explains why the device tree is not loading. CONFIG_OF_CONFIGFS=y is the important part.
Later in that post I checked the raspbian kernel config from my running RP400 for that option and it is there, but when I downloaded a RT arm64 kernel from debian and run grep on the kernel config it wasn't there. If the option was available it would have an N instead of Y.
Yep I had the kernel modules loading but no /dev entries under bookworm.

This explains the device tree far better than I could
docs.kernel.org/devicetree/overlay-notes.html

What lead me down this hole was when I was messing around with Linuxcnc-RIO which uses an ICE40 fpga and communicates via SPI. It would just not work under Debain Bookworm, but was fine with Bullseye. I don't want to recall how much time I spent.......and I only found out about the info I posted about above yesterday.

You seem all worried about not using the device tree. I don't believe the device tree is the only way to solve the problem.
The problem that is my immediate concern load_rt hm2_rpspi is working with spi on Bookworm. I now have a RaspberryPi OS 11 (Bullseye) disk that I can load when I need to run mesaflash.
My lower priority concern is trying to get mesaflash to run on Bookworm without device trees. I found the driver source for spi.c and spidev.c in the Bookworm preempt rt kernel that I am running.

As PCW said
"but mesaflash does require the SPI device driver "

Which you wont have if you can't load the device tree overlay.
Anyways good luck.

Playing around with Bookworm first mesaflash is without a board connected, second is with board connected.

rmurphy@rpi4-20230612:~$ cat /etc/debian_version
12.0
rmurphy@rpi4-20230612:~$ ls /dev/spi*
/dev/spidev0.0 /dev/spidev0.1
rmurphy@rpi4-20230612:~$ sudo mesaflash --device 7c81 --addr /dev/spidev0.0 --spi --readhmid
sudo: unable to resolve host rpi4-20230612: Name or service not known
unable to set bpw32, fallback to bpw8
Unexpected cookie at 0100..0110:
00000000 00000000 00000000
No 7C81 board found
rmurphy@rpi4-20230612:~$ sudo mesaflash --device 7c81 --addr /dev/spidev0.0 --spi --readhmid
sudo: unable to resolve host rpi4-20230612: Name or service not known
unable to set bpw32, fallback to bpw8
Configuration Name: HOSTMOT2

General configuration information:

BoardName : MESA7C81
FPGA Size: 9 KGates
FPGA Pins: 144
Number of IO Ports: 3
Width of one I/O port: 19
Clock Low frequency: 100.0000 MHz
Clock High frequency: 200.0000 MHz
IDROM Type: 3
Instance Stride 0: 4
Instance Stride 1: 64
Register Stride 0: 256
Register Stride 1: 256

Modules in configuration:

Module: DPLL
There are 1 of DPLL in configuration
Version: 0
Registers: 7
BaseAddress: 7000
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Module: WatchDog
There are 1 of WatchDog in configuration
Version: 0
Registers: 3
BaseAddress: 0C00
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Module: IOPort
There are 3 of IOPort in configuration
Version: 0
Registers: 5
BaseAddress: 1000
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Module: QCount
There are 1 of QCount in configuration
Version: 2
Registers: 5
BaseAddress: 3000
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Module: SSerial
There are 1 of SSerial in configuration
Version: 0
Registers: 6
BaseAddress: 5B00
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 64 bytes

Module: StepGen
There are 3 of StepGen in configuration
Version: 2
Registers: 10
BaseAddress: 2000
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Module: PWM
There are 2 of PWM in configuration
Version: 0
Registers: 5
BaseAddress: 4100
ClockFrequency: 200.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Module: InM
There are 2 of InM in configuration
Version: 0
Registers: 5
BaseAddress: 8500
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Module: LED
There are 1 of LED in configuration
Version: 0
Registers: 1
BaseAddress: 0200
ClockFrequency: 100.000 MHz
Register Stride: 256 bytes
Instance Stride: 4 bytes

Configuration pin-out:

IO Connections for P1+Serial -> 7C81_0
Pin# I/O Pri. func Sec. func Chan Sec. Pin func Sec. Pin Dir

P1-01/DB25-01 0 IOPort StepGen 0 Step/Table1 (Out)
P1-02/DB25-14 1 IOPort None
P1-03/DB25-02 2 IOPort None
P1-04/DB25-15 3 IOPort None
P1-05/DB25-03 4 IOPort None
P1-06/DB25-16 5 IOPort InM 0 Input0 (In)
P1-07/DB25-04 6 IOPort InM 0 Input1 (In)
P1-08/DB25-17 7 IOPort InM 0 Input2 (In)
P1-09/DB25-05 8 IOPort InM 0 Input3 (In)
P1-11/DB25-06 9 IOPort QCount 0 Quad-A (In)
P1-13/DB25-07 10 IOPort QCount 0 Quad-B (In)
P1-15/DB25-08 11 IOPort QCount 0 Quad-IDX (In)
P1-17/DB25-09 12 IOPort None
P1-19/DB25-10 13 IOPort StepGen 0 Dir/Table2 (Out)
P1-21/DB25-11 14 IOPort None
P1-23/DB25-12 15 IOPort StepGen 2 Step/Table1 (Out)
P1-25/DB25-13 16 IOPort StepGen 2 Dir/Table2 (Out)
P5 3,6 17 IOPort SSerial 0 TXData0 (Out)
P6 3,6 18 IOPort SSerial 0 TXData1 (Out)

IO Connections for P2+Serial -> 7C81_1
Pin# I/O Pri. func Sec. func Chan Sec. Pin func Sec. Pin Dir

P2-01/DB25-01 19 IOPort StepGen 1 Step/Table1 (Out)
P2-02/DB25-14 20 IOPort None
P2-03/DB25-02 21 IOPort None
P2-04/DB25-15 22 IOPort InM 1 Input0 (In)
P2-05/DB25-03 23 IOPort InM 1 Input1 (In)
P2-06/DB25-16 24 IOPort InM 1 Input2 (In)
P2-07/DB25-04 25 IOPort InM 1 Input3 (In)
P2-08/DB25-17 26 IOPort InM 1 Input4 (In)
P2-09/DB25-05 27 IOPort InM 1 Input5 (In)
P2-11/DB25-06 28 IOPort None
P2-13/DB25-07 29 IOPort None
P2-15/DB25-08 30 IOPort None
P2-17/DB25-09 31 IOPort None
P2-19/DB25-10 32 IOPort StepGen 1 Dir/Table2 (Out)
P2-21/DB25-11 33 IOPort None
P2-23/DB25-12 34 IOPort PWM 0 PWM (Out)
P2-25/DB25-13 35 IOPort None
P5 TXEN 36 IOPort SSerial 0 TXEn0 (Out)
P6 TXEN 37 IOPort SSerial 0 TXEn1 (Out)

IO Connections for P7+Serial -> 7C81_2
Pin# I/O Pri. func Sec. func Chan Sec. Pin func Sec. Pin Dir

P7-01/DB25-01 38 IOPort None
P7-02/DB25-14 39 IOPort None
P7-03/DB25-02 40 IOPort None
P7-04/DB25-15 41 IOPort None
P7-05/DB25-03 42 IOPort None
P7-06/DB25-16 43 IOPort None
P7-07/DB25-04 44 IOPort None
P7-08/DB25-17 45 IOPort None
P7-09/DB25-05 46 IOPort None
P7-11/DB25-06 47 IOPort None
P7-13/DB25-07 48 IOPort None
P7-15/DB25-08 49 IOPort None
P7-17/DB25-09 50 IOPort None
P7-19/DB25-10 51 IOPort None
P7-21/DB25-11 52 IOPort None
P7-23/DB25-12 53 IOPort None
P7-25/DB25-13 54 IOPort None
P5 1,2 55 IOPort SSerial 0 RXData0 (In)
P6 1,2 56 IOPort SSerial 0 RXData1 (In)