Rotary Table Tuning Problems
- schmidtmotorworks
- Offline
- Elite Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 286
- Thank you received: 6
13 Nov 2016 07:33 - 13 Nov 2016 07:34 #82734
by schmidtmotorworks
Replied by schmidtmotorworks on topic Rotary Table Tuning Problems
Update, I finally got it working, after trying everything I could think of several times I cut the connectors off the cables and soldered them again and to my surprise it instantly worked perfectly. It looked like there was some metallic dust inside some of them. Maybe the way I was testing continuity wasn't finding unwanted continuity.
After trying maybe 100s of times, when it finally worked it was difficult to believe when I turned it on and it is silent. I assumed I must have forgot to connect something. Just to be sure I turned the hand-wheel and the table moved smoothly; what? No way, It moved, it must be a coincidence.
The thought actually crossed my mind that maybe this is a dream and i am going to wake up in a minute.
.
After trying maybe 100s of times, when it finally worked it was difficult to believe when I turned it on and it is silent. I assumed I must have forgot to connect something. Just to be sure I turned the hand-wheel and the table moved smoothly; what? No way, It moved, it must be a coincidence.
The thought actually crossed my mind that maybe this is a dream and i am going to wake up in a minute.
.
Last edit: 13 Nov 2016 07:34 by schmidtmotorworks.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- schmidtmotorworks
- Offline
- Elite Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 286
- Thank you received: 6
17 Nov 2016 08:13 #82882
by schmidtmotorworks
Replied by schmidtmotorworks on topic Rotary Table Tuning Problems
Well, there seems to be one last problem.
When the rotary table is moving, at certain spots (always the same spot) it skips ahead about 1 degree, that is about 5 degrees on the motor with a 2000 step per resolution encoder.
I have tried most PID and other variables and it doesn't seem the change anything about the skipping at all,
I am guessing that maybe the encoder has a problem. It is new from US Digital, but I guess it could be defective.
The only other thing that comes to mind is I don't have the index wires connected on the encoder, only A-A and B-B, V+ and Ground. My connector has a problem and I am waiting for a new one to arrive. It seems to update the position on the screen OK without the index wires connected. I wonder if they are read or not for an axis?
Another possibility I guess could be the motor but it seems to run smoothly when the encoder is disconnected. I just disconnect the encoder and turn the jog handle a little and the motor and table turns smoothly..
When the rotary table is moving, at certain spots (always the same spot) it skips ahead about 1 degree, that is about 5 degrees on the motor with a 2000 step per resolution encoder.
I have tried most PID and other variables and it doesn't seem the change anything about the skipping at all,
I am guessing that maybe the encoder has a problem. It is new from US Digital, but I guess it could be defective.
The only other thing that comes to mind is I don't have the index wires connected on the encoder, only A-A and B-B, V+ and Ground. My connector has a problem and I am waiting for a new one to arrive. It seems to update the position on the screen OK without the index wires connected. I wonder if they are read or not for an axis?
Another possibility I guess could be the motor but it seems to run smoothly when the encoder is disconnected. I just disconnect the encoder and turn the jog handle a little and the motor and table turns smoothly..
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
17 Nov 2016 10:20 #82883
by andypugh
Replied by andypugh on topic Rotary Table Tuning Problems
Index on an axis is only used during homing, and even then only if explicitly enabled.
Do you have access to a oscilloscope to look at the actual encoder pulses?
If the problem exists when moving very slowly it might be possible to use Halscope to monitor encoder edges.
Do you have access to a oscilloscope to look at the actual encoder pulses?
If the problem exists when moving very slowly it might be possible to use Halscope to monitor encoder edges.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- schmidtmotorworks
- Offline
- Elite Member
-
Less
More
- Posts: 286
- Thank you received: 6
17 Nov 2016 20:56 #82928
by schmidtmotorworks
Replied by schmidtmotorworks on topic Rotary Table Tuning Problems
I don't have a scope, it does look like a fun toy though.
I just discussed this with the encoder manufacturer, he said it does sound like an encoder problem and asked me to send it in.
I just discussed this with the encoder manufacturer, he said it does sound like an encoder problem and asked me to send it in.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.120 seconds