×
Forum Header
No progress after using stepconfig.
- awetmore
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 32
- Thank you received: 5
06 Feb 2010 15:45 #1790
by awetmore
Replied by awetmore on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
I've had issues with the Y axis as well. It seems like the homing switches on X and Z work as described, but the Y axis homing switch is both acting as a homing switch and a Y-axis emergency stop switch. When I run the motor that far it stops working. To recover I've been cranking the Y axis by hand away from the limit switch, then jogging.
I figured out that the pins were being read differently by stepconf and axis by looking at "halcmd show" as suggested in this thread. The pins were having different outputs when I ran under Axis vs under Stepconf.
Now I'm trying to figure out if I need to match EMC's chop clock to the driver's chop clock. It looks like these drivers are designed for a 40k chop clock. I've noticed that my torque just seems pretty compared to what I'd expect. I have PowerMax II steppers which should have a torque of 210 in-oz configured in a 4-wire bipolar setup.
I figured out that the pins were being read differently by stepconf and axis by looking at "halcmd show" as suggested in this thread. The pins were having different outputs when I ran under Axis vs under Stepconf.
Now I'm trying to figure out if I need to match EMC's chop clock to the driver's chop clock. It looks like these drivers are designed for a 40k chop clock. I've noticed that my torque just seems pretty compared to what I'd expect. I have PowerMax II steppers which should have a torque of 210 in-oz configured in a 4-wire bipolar setup.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- awetmore
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 32
- Thank you received: 5
06 Feb 2010 15:58 #1791
by awetmore
Replied by awetmore on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
Did Dennis give you any advice on the proper timings for the first page of stepconf? Are you just using the L297 configuration?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- grey1beard
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 154
- Thank you received: 0
06 Feb 2010 16:29 - 06 Feb 2010 16:54 #1793
by grey1beard
Replied by grey1beard on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
He may have done, but not as far as I can remember.
I'm just using the standard L297 option in stepconfig.
I've got the powermax II as well.
Would you like me to email you the circuit diag. if it's any help. I have it as a pdf.
The little grey cells can keep up, but somewhat slower than they used to be.
I was trained on digital logic just 50 years ago, and it's coming back very slowly.
John
I'm just using the standard L297 option in stepconfig.
I've got the powermax II as well.
Would you like me to email you the circuit diag. if it's any help. I have it as a pdf.
The little grey cells can keep up, but somewhat slower than they used to be.
I was trained on digital logic just 50 years ago, and it's coming back very slowly.
John
Last edit: 06 Feb 2010 16:54 by grey1beard.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- grey1beard
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 154
- Thank you received: 0
06 Feb 2010 17:09 #1795
by grey1beard
Replied by grey1beard on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
Well, here I go again sticking my neck out.
The beast is cutting air successfully.
I went out to the workshop, opened up stepconfig, and instead of doing what I'd previously posted, I changed two pin configs and tried it. For no known logic, I seem to have hit the right set up.
1 Estop............................................10 Unused
2 X step...........................................11 Min + Home X inverted
3 X dir..............................................12 Min + Home Y inverted
4 Y step...........................................13 Min + Home Z inverted
5 Y dir....................... inverted........15 Unused
6 Unused
7 Unused
8 Z step
9 Z dir.........................inverted
14 Amp enabled .... inverted
16 Amp enabled
17 Amp enabled
Just posting this for reference for anyone else with the same hardware, and having similar problems.
Thanks all, but I've still got the limit switch and homing to sort out yet, so I shall return !!!
John
The beast is cutting air successfully.
I went out to the workshop, opened up stepconfig, and instead of doing what I'd previously posted, I changed two pin configs and tried it. For no known logic, I seem to have hit the right set up.
1 Estop............................................10 Unused
2 X step...........................................11 Min + Home X inverted
3 X dir..............................................12 Min + Home Y inverted
4 Y step...........................................13 Min + Home Z inverted
5 Y dir....................... inverted........15 Unused
6 Unused
7 Unused
8 Z step
9 Z dir.........................inverted
14 Amp enabled .... inverted
16 Amp enabled
17 Amp enabled
Just posting this for reference for anyone else with the same hardware, and having similar problems.
Thanks all, but I've still got the limit switch and homing to sort out yet, so I shall return !!!
John
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- BigJohnT
- Offline
- Administrator
Less
More
- Posts: 7000
- Thank you received: 1172
07 Feb 2010 02:29 #1798
by BigJohnT
Replied by BigJohnT on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
John,
Glad you got some progress. Just keep plugging away at it and you will get there.
I assume you are an old fart like me, a little slower sometimes but don't lack any enthusiasm for life.
John
Glad you got some progress. Just keep plugging away at it and you will get there.
I assume you are an old fart like me, a little slower sometimes but don't lack any enthusiasm for life.
John
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- grey1beard
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 154
- Thank you received: 0
07 Feb 2010 09:13 - 07 Feb 2010 11:36 #1800
by grey1beard
Replied by grey1beard on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
BigJohnT wrote:
Heading for 72 next birthday, but I find avoiding green vegetables helps
I have a sneaky suspicion that my subconscious is pushing me into cnc so that I can build myself another, power assisted body.
Wind powered, of course
John
.............I assume you are an old fart like me,.....................
Heading for 72 next birthday, but I find avoiding green vegetables helps
I have a sneaky suspicion that my subconscious is pushing me into cnc so that I can build myself another, power assisted body.
Wind powered, of course
John
Last edit: 07 Feb 2010 11:36 by BigJohnT.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- grey1beard
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 154
- Thank you received: 0
07 Feb 2010 13:48 #1801
by grey1beard
Replied by grey1beard on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
Well, well, well. A revelation
All the problems I'm having with setting up "homing", all come down to the idea that my machine (or me) "don't know which way is up".
Or rather, in this case, up/down is OK, but it doesn't know its XY from its elbow.
I couldn't understand why the gantry went off looking for the home switch in the wrong direction.
So I've just printed off the Integrators manual pages for Homing, pp 38-41, and sat staring at the diagrams and reading the text.
I now suspect that my machine and the software don't agree on what is being moved, the tool or the table.
In stepconfig it says "table travel", but I'm moving the tool, and the significance of that passed me by.
So, while I ponder that, another question springs to mind.
I've got an N/C limit switch at each end of the table wired in series for X axis and simillar on the gantry for Y and Z.
I've set the stepconfig to "minimum limit + home" for each, and I've got the latch direction "Same".
Is this correct ?
At the moment, the homing search is going the wrong way if home is 0,0,0, and it's trying to go to the final home position in the wrong direction !!
John
All the problems I'm having with setting up "homing", all come down to the idea that my machine (or me) "don't know which way is up".
Or rather, in this case, up/down is OK, but it doesn't know its XY from its elbow.
I couldn't understand why the gantry went off looking for the home switch in the wrong direction.
So I've just printed off the Integrators manual pages for Homing, pp 38-41, and sat staring at the diagrams and reading the text.
I now suspect that my machine and the software don't agree on what is being moved, the tool or the table.
In stepconfig it says "table travel", but I'm moving the tool, and the significance of that passed me by.
So, while I ponder that, another question springs to mind.
I've got an N/C limit switch at each end of the table wired in series for X axis and simillar on the gantry for Y and Z.
I've set the stepconfig to "minimum limit + home" for each, and I've got the latch direction "Same".
Is this correct ?
At the moment, the homing search is going the wrong way if home is 0,0,0, and it's trying to go to the final home position in the wrong direction !!
John
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- awetmore
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 32
- Thank you received: 5
07 Feb 2010 16:04 #1804
by awetmore
Replied by awetmore on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
I was very confused by that as well, then found the answer hidden in some FAQ. Put a - (negative) in front of the speed for looking for the homing switch. That will make it move in the opposite direction.
I still don't have homing working on my Y, but it works well on my X and Z. I have all three set to Home only, not Home+Limit, although I guess both would work.
I still don't have homing working on my Y, but it works well on my X and Z. I have all three set to Home only, not Home+Limit, although I guess both would work.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- grey1beard
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 154
- Thank you received: 0
07 Feb 2010 16:47 #1805
by grey1beard
Replied by grey1beard on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
Thanks Alex, I've just done the restting on the X and Y direction, and it now works on all three axis.
Regards
John
Regards
John
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- grey1beard
- Offline
- Premium Member
Less
More
- Posts: 154
- Thank you received: 0
07 Feb 2010 18:49 - 07 Feb 2010 20:19 #1806
by grey1beard
Replied by grey1beard on topic Re:No progress after using stepconfig.
This may be final request on this thread, asked here because it's part of the same learning process.
I would like to print out a couple of files - the ini and hal files- which showing on screen in the workshop in gedit are easy to read.
But my printer is in the house on my xp laptop, and I can use a memory stick to get the data there v. easily.
However, it opens in notebook, and as gedit doesn't add any formatting, the layout makes it all but useless.
I can turn it into a pdf, and it has some formatting, but it sees it as an image, not something I can make printer friendly.
Can someone advise how I jump this hurdle ?
John
EDIT
I can only open the ini file in notepad, not the hal file.
I would like to print out a couple of files - the ini and hal files- which showing on screen in the workshop in gedit are easy to read.
But my printer is in the house on my xp laptop, and I can use a memory stick to get the data there v. easily.
However, it opens in notebook, and as gedit doesn't add any formatting, the layout makes it all but useless.
I can turn it into a pdf, and it has some formatting, but it sees it as an image, not something I can make printer friendly.
Can someone advise how I jump this hurdle ?
John
EDIT
I can only open the ini file in notepad, not the hal file.
Last edit: 07 Feb 2010 20:19 by grey1beard.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.070 seconds