Advanced Search

Yes, same as those. I had seen the success case from dschultz in there around the middle of the thread, which is encouraging, but I'm mostly polling on thoughts from people that might have succeeded with them and not ended up coming back to post about. Also, in general about anything that I might not be considering about my linuxCNC + ethercat in one go.

Are those the same as this:
forum.linuxcnc.org/ethercat/54965-stepperonline-a6-servo

Sorry, pasted the image, and it looked good, but apparently it ended up referencing a discord image. Here it is.

Hello folks, this is my first post!

I've currently got a mach 3 based 3 axis CNC, and i'm building another one (which for these purposes can be thought of as a printNC in terms of design, dual drive for the main axis, single for the rest) for which I plan was reuse the control box, based on open loop steppers, to get it going and then migrate to linuxCNC. I still got some months ahead of me on that build and time to change my mind and do something about the controller sooner. I've no experience configuring linuxCNC but i'm a developer doing stuff i've never done is basically what we do.

I'd like to go all the way to the other end of the spectrum with ethercat servos. Thesem plus a small ethercat IO module would allow me to skip mesa cards. Given that premise, what do you guys think of these servos? (Try to ignore the fact that i'd have to pay more in shipping and taxes for them than the hardware is worth. That is just the reality for me living in AR and would apply to all alternatives similarly)
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/1332732662107869308/1494434027028091041/Screenshot_2026-04-16_at_5.24.53_PM.png?ex=69e297a5&is=69e14625&hm=fc0960a66f042b806facd98201b57cecbe5abb092fd39c1c1cd010140933690c&=&format=webp&quality=lossless
Now, i KNOW i'm not buying leadshine or get 1 click tuning. I'm not asking if it'll be easy to get it going, I know it won't be trivial. I want to know if there's enough to read that i could get them working, and when i do, will i be happy with how they perform. Now, I've looked around and there are definitely people using these servos, asking questions, and other people responding to them, but they never seem to post some nice shiny video of they machine working in the end which is what worries me.

if there's anything regarding my build that'll affect the response let me know and i'll add it. Thanks a bunch!
 

Well that was easy.

 

This is really, really nice for the computer Luddites.

Thank you JT!

@BULGARIAN,
No double posting.

I do not use GmoccaPy, but i would choose first version as it is much easier to use fast and when it becomes reflex.
Thank you.

Hi Axemas
,
Thank you very much—after making the changes, it worked
immediately. A huge thank you!
I agree with what Surmetall wrote; a feature like that would be very helpful.
However, regarding some minor tweaks—which I hope are simple for you to fix—setting the width of the NC tab—
“Master treeview minimal width” in Preferences
doesn’t work. This results in a lot of screen space for parameters and a very small project display area, but as I mentioned, this is just a cosmetic issue.
Thanks again, and I hope the community of Nativecam enthusiasts—of which I am one—will grow significantly.
Zbigi

It does make some sense to me that the commanded position would stay ahead by some bit so that it doesn't instantly get massive following error, but am not sure at this point. It comes from joint.n.motor-pos-cmd. I've attached the config files here

Furthermore, while on Debian 12 and Debian Trixie the Grub command line has been optimized, with isolcpu, c state, etc., in Debian 10 there are no optimizations. Obviously I tried to remove the optimizations on Debian 12 and Trixie, as well as on Debian 10, but the problem persists, only on Debian 12 and Trixie.

¿Cómo están? Es mi primera vez por acá, me encuentro en la situación de querer actualizar un torno CNC Emco Turn 55-ii con mis compañeros de la tecnicatura de Mecatrónica, el torno se encuentra y es parte de una Escuela técnica de argentina. Vengo en búsqueda de opiniones, experiencias y quien dice; algún manual de cableado del torno. Todo es agradecido. Espero que se encuentren bien.

​I'm currently working on an upgrade project for an Emco Turn 55-II lathe located at a local school.
​I’m looking for the wiring manual or electrical schematics for this machine. I’m not entirely sure which of the two versions it is, so if anyone happens to have documentation for either (or both), it would be a huge help so I can compare them and move forward with the project.
​Any help or guidance on where to find these would be greatly appreciated!
​Thanks in advance.
Please excuse any mistakes in my English, as I am using a translator to write this

deomon wrote:

I think the popup of any kind is not strictly necessary but possibility to change value by sliding the slider are most welcome. Especially by users of capacitive Touchscreens. Original solution I think was created for resistive touchscreens where the +- buttons still are viable solution as sliding there would not work well.

I have a resistive touchscreen and this works quite well.

Good morning everyone. After several tests I had to leave the machine to the customer with Debian 10. Believe me, I tried everything. It seemed to work with the refClockSyncCycles setting to 1, but sometimes the motors, when the PC was started for the first time, made noise. Turning it off and on again is fine and when it works well, it works well for a long time. I even tried Debian 12, the Git ISO and ethercat 1.6.3, but even worse than Trixie. I put back the Debian 10 HD and ethercat 1.5.2 and it still works fine, even if at first glance, in addition to the fact that with Debian 10, the drive values ​​are read instantly when the PC starts, while with Debian 12 and Trixie, you have to wait a few seconds. And in my opinion, everything starts from this problem. I set latency-histogram --nobase --sbins 1000 --show, stressed the PC, with gear, opening the browser (not connected), moved windows, opened librecad etc., but Debian 10 has maximum and minimum latency half of Debian 12 and Trixie, same PC. I think the problem is between the RT kernel and the Ethercat version. For example, I tested the Debian 10 pins with Ethercat 1.5.2. The pll-error value oscillates between -2200 and 1600. The pll-out pin has a fixed value of 1000 or -1000. Why don't we try installing Ethercat 1.5.2 on Trixie, so as to understand if the problem is on the kernel or Ethercat side. I think that on the Icec side, there is little to do. Yes, we're certainly trying to optimize, but the main problem is latency and jitter stability. I remain available. Luca, I wrote to you privately, but you haven't responded.

I think the popup of any kind is not strictly necessary but possibility to change value by sliding the slider are most welcome. Especially by users of capacitive Touchscreens. Original solution I think was created for resistive touchscreens where the +- buttons still are viable solution as sliding there would not work well.