Advanced Search

To be perfectly honest your issue is somewhat out the scope of the support found on the forum.
It is quite obvious you installed the remote software on the RPi, as I didn't build the image with any remote connection software other than SSH.
Your best bet would be to try the various Debian forums, the raspberry pi forums usually deal with issues with Raspios.
The RPi images are Debian Bookworm, with the kernel source from the RPi sources and Linuxcnc packages installed.
The images are not expected to be run via any remote desktop, hence the reason no remote desktop software is included, nor is it expected to be used as a general purpose OS.
What is your reason to run remotely ?
And please no double posting. My apologies I got confused by another user that was having the same issue.

Hi,
When I try to log in with rdp from windows 11, it accepts user and pass, but after the image displays something pixelated as if there were 100 miniature desktop . Has anyone else experienced this? (rpi 4 4gb ). Everything else works ok so far..

Ethercat Update Sun, 16th Feb 2025

Ethercat installs and kernel modules build, some will build for running kernel, some build for 6.1.x kernel, but load with just a message about tainting kernel in logs. Just need someone with Ethercat hardware to confirm operation.

@rodw,
I'm very grateful. The suggested external offsets operate in a manner comparable to what I require. I plan to try integrating them with my current Raspberry Pi setup.

Ethercat appears to install ok, some modules are built for the current kernel, some are built for 6.1.0-31-arm64.

With no Ethercat devices connected I get this, would this indicate a good install ?

bring your remora related discussion into this thread

www.forum.linuxcnc.org/18-computer/42276...rocontroller-via-spi

and upload your hal/ini files using the forums attachments please

I spent some hours..

1) flashed the octopus MCU with dfu-util
2) draft version of HAL and INI files done
3) wiring pi5 correctly to the octopus
4) pi5 is running remora flexi os

The error is from linux cnc when it loads my config: joint.5.scale pin doesnt exist. If I do a show pin with halcmd it shows a bunch of joints unit joint.4.

HAL file
INI file

Remote desktop has issues.

Set the CPU scaling governor to performance.

The Raspberry Pi might not be powerful enough for that.

In the meantime I solved the issue. I connected the Raspberry Pi gpio output pin to motion.digital-in-00 and now I can read this RPI output pin with M66. No need for a macro anymore...

Basic Mill Config Using hal_gpio

forum.linuxcnc.org/media/kunena/attachme...8/my-mill-config.zip
Link to driver:
linuxcnc.org/docs/devel/html/drivers/hal_gpio.html

Note unless SPI is disabled in /boot/broadcom/config.txt GPIO07 & GPIO08 can not be used.

amanker wrote:

Yes. I wanted to communicate via spi only. Since I also configured it in spi mode in daisy chain config in FluidNC. Remora communicate with LinuxCNC via spi. If possible I can send spi config data to tmc via some module in LinuxCNC. Or if you modded remora-spi source to suit tmc 5160
 

If you can make a direct SPI connection between the Raspberry Pi and the TMC drivers, then it should be very easy to adapt my code; all it does is sending the registers value to the drivers according to values you set via parameters until all the registers have been set, and then it reads the motor position. And another function sends velocity command. You'd just need to remove the write velocity part (or, simply said, not addf TMC5160.write) and not connect the position feedback pin. In theory you could still use the SPI line to get TMC status bit and be informed if one driver has an error.

I want to try to control the SPI device on the RPi without the use of BCM2835 library to avoid compatibility problems. Give me a week to try and I'll publish my code after that. I didn't even try to modify the spi-remora code, as this is way above my coding skills.

If you are doing 3d printing have a look at the remora

github.com/scottalford75/Remora

If you had of read the docs, the parts regarding using a parallel port and software step generation, you would have learnt that there is a limit to the stepper speed based on the latency of the base thread.
This is the problem, people don't fully research/read the docs and don't fully understand what they are doing. They also assume things that are not so.
Many times people blame Linuxcnc, 99% of the time it is a mistake they have made.
The recent rise in the availability of home CNC machines has led people to think it is easy thing to setup and use. It's not, there are many hats you have to wear. And to be fair the basis for a project for Linuxcnc, all those years ago, was for control of industrial machines. I don't think the original authors of the papers imagined the extent that small CNC machines would become available to the "average Joe".
Checkout the mesa website, see what they have available. Read the forums, see what other people are doing. Checkout the remora project, have a look at Linuxcnc-RIO, geesh I even gave a link to my own GitHub project.

I'm sorry if my previous post was hard to understand or based on misread info. 

I was under the assumption that the most affordable mesa card for 6 axis (5 move and 1 extr) was around 200 bucks. But you are totally right better to ask than assume... I'm sorry for sounding stupid.

I'm still very much open to guidance for hardware selection for my 5 axis printer

Have a great day!

Hobby 3-axis mill, Raspberry Pi 4B, official download - reports as Gmoccapy 3.4.6.
Done several jobs since swapping from AXIS.

Running code - then stop.
No pop-up messages.
Found the Gmoccapy Log - nothing.

Cancelled job, but machine would not jog.
De-activate controls (Green/Red PB), then activate - machine jogs.

Need some hints on where to look, or a list of typical problems.
Thanks,
John.