Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
14 Jul 2020 22:28 - 14 Jul 2020 22:44 #174667
by PCW
Replied by PCW on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
OK if its only CR4 that's illuminated (not CR3 which is also red)
This may be a side effect of crashing, but if CR4 illuminates
and LinuxCNC is still running this means that the watchdog has bitten
If both CR3 and CR4 illuminate, that's a power issue
Debian corrupted: Unlikely
two out of three 5V PSU not suitable: Will not cause Linux to crash as long as you are not connected to and causing a problem with PC 5V
better grounding due common Poweroutlet: I suspect a grounding or EMI issue since every thing runs when not connected to the MAHO
corrupted mesa 5i25 firmware: Not really possible as its CRC checked and will not start if corrupted
This may be a side effect of crashing, but if CR4 illuminates
and LinuxCNC is still running this means that the watchdog has bitten
If both CR3 and CR4 illuminate, that's a power issue
Debian corrupted: Unlikely
two out of three 5V PSU not suitable: Will not cause Linux to crash as long as you are not connected to and causing a problem with PC 5V
better grounding due common Poweroutlet: I suspect a grounding or EMI issue since every thing runs when not connected to the MAHO
corrupted mesa 5i25 firmware: Not really possible as its CRC checked and will not start if corrupted
Last edit: 14 Jul 2020 22:44 by PCW.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
15 Jul 2020 13:32 #174748
by Onkelmat
Replied by Onkelmat on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
The system crashes only with the scales connected. Maho doesnt even need to be powered. It only crashes when the 5V and 0V to the scales are connected.
The Mesa card seems to be ok. The Cr4 only burns when a crash has happened, or it has crashed until next start of linuxcnc.
Today i have changed the cables to shielded ones and could only improve the ttl signal now itś nice and crisp.
on the 5i25 the is a pinheader for 3.3V and GND. when i measure it with a multimeter it shows 3.3V
when i hook up my oscilloscope it shows something between 2,8V and XX. cant read due fast switching. Guess thatś ok too.
The most strange thing to me is still. that the pc ONLY crashes when LinuxCNC is running. iḿ writing from the linuxcnc pc now. its on for like 10 minutes.
when id start linuxcnc now. it would instant crash.
how can i see what linux does right at start that interacts with the encoders ?
The Mesa card seems to be ok. The Cr4 only burns when a crash has happened, or it has crashed until next start of linuxcnc.
Today i have changed the cables to shielded ones and could only improve the ttl signal now itś nice and crisp.
on the 5i25 the is a pinheader for 3.3V and GND. when i measure it with a multimeter it shows 3.3V
when i hook up my oscilloscope it shows something between 2,8V and XX. cant read due fast switching. Guess thatś ok too.
The most strange thing to me is still. that the pc ONLY crashes when LinuxCNC is running. iḿ writing from the linuxcnc pc now. its on for like 10 minutes.
when id start linuxcnc now. it would instant crash.
how can i see what linux does right at start that interacts with the encoders ?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
15 Jul 2020 14:03 - 15 Jul 2020 14:13 #174751
by PCW
You would expect a clean 3.3V at that pin
If its really noisy it suggests a grounding or EMI issue
BTW the 3.3V pin on the programming header connects directly to the PC 3.3V,
be _very_ careful that you do not short it to ground
Will LinuxCNC run if you disconnect all 7I77 encoder and analog connections?
That is, anything that connects to the MAHOs ground. You may also have to
dismount the 7I77 if its bolted to a control box frame (the 2 mounting holes on the
DB25 end of the 7I77 are grounded)
Also is the PC in a case?
(I suspect a ground loop)
Replied by PCW on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
when i hook up my oscilloscope it shows something between 2,8V and XX. cant read due fast switching. Guess thatś ok too.
You would expect a clean 3.3V at that pin
If its really noisy it suggests a grounding or EMI issue
BTW the 3.3V pin on the programming header connects directly to the PC 3.3V,
be _very_ careful that you do not short it to ground
Will LinuxCNC run if you disconnect all 7I77 encoder and analog connections?
That is, anything that connects to the MAHOs ground. You may also have to
dismount the 7I77 if its bolted to a control box frame (the 2 mounting holes on the
DB25 end of the 7I77 are grounded)
Also is the PC in a case?
(I suspect a ground loop)
Last edit: 15 Jul 2020 14:13 by PCW.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
15 Jul 2020 14:15 - 15 Jul 2020 15:14 #174752
by Onkelmat
Replied by Onkelmat on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
I ve disconnected the encoder pairs one by one to see if one of them is causing the problem.
Pair one did no change
Pair two did no change
Pair three seems to be affecting my problem.
Itś the direction pair. When its disconnected the PC doesnt crash. its on since last post with linuxcnc running. no crash.
When i check with the osci it shows some ttl signal but Vmax sometimes goes to + or - 14V
If i try to check that voltage with the multimeter it only shows 3.2V more or less.
The 12v seems to appear when i start turning the axis.
I ll investigate. :>
EDIT 1:
saw your complete last post now:
quick reply.
Only 5v to TB1
24V to TB8 (the orange one) not sure about the number right now
and 3x encoders on the top row, close to the db25 cable.
Maho not connected only ground connected, mains off.
pc is laying on the floor on cardboard xD
7i77 floating midair
EDIT 2:
Linuxcnc was running for like 35 Minutes without crash and the direction pair disconnected. then the pc crashed again.
Iḿ now at a point where every pair is removed and only 5v and 0V is connected to the encoders. Every other combination failed.
Pair two did no change
Pair three seems to be affecting my problem.
Itś the direction pair. When its disconnected the PC doesnt crash. its on since last post with linuxcnc running. no crash.
When i check with the osci it shows some ttl signal but Vmax sometimes goes to + or - 14V
If i try to check that voltage with the multimeter it only shows 3.2V more or less.
The 12v seems to appear when i start turning the axis.
I ll investigate. :>
EDIT 1:
saw your complete last post now:
quick reply.
Only 5v to TB1
24V to TB8 (the orange one) not sure about the number right now
and 3x encoders on the top row, close to the db25 cable.
Maho not connected only ground connected, mains off.
pc is laying on the floor on cardboard xD
7i77 floating midair
EDIT 2:
Linuxcnc was running for like 35 Minutes without crash and the direction pair disconnected. then the pc crashed again.
Iḿ now at a point where every pair is removed and only 5v and 0V is connected to the encoders. Every other combination failed.
Last edit: 15 Jul 2020 15:14 by Onkelmat.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
15 Jul 2020 15:36 #174755
by PCW
Replied by PCW on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
Right, if its a ground loop issue, 5V and ground connections to anything on the MAHO are the issue
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
15 Jul 2020 16:17 - 15 Jul 2020 17:19 #174759
by Onkelmat
Replied by Onkelmat on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
Okay now that are all connections:
5V PSU to TB1 -> 5V and GND
24V PSU to TB2 -> 24V and GND
TB2 NC -> shielding of the cables of scales
DB25 7i77 >-> DB25 5i25
TB3 Pin3 -> 0V Exe card channel 1
TB3 Pin6 -> +5V Exe card channel 1
TB3 Pin 11 -> 0V Channel 2
TB3 Pin 14 -> +5V Channel 2
channel 3 same setup.
This seems to work so far, no crash since 30 minutes
EDIT: when i unplug the 5v psu the pc crashes sometimes too, thatś new...
EDIT 2: connected one scale...worked fine for 30 Minutes
connected another one, worked fine for 15 minutes.
wanted to edit this post to report good progress and booom crash
So all electrical components are run from one multi socket thingy. the only extra ground run is the one from the 24v PSU to the TB2 socket.
5V PSU to TB1 -> 5V and GND
24V PSU to TB2 -> 24V and GND
TB2 NC -> shielding of the cables of scales
DB25 7i77 >-> DB25 5i25
TB3 Pin3 -> 0V Exe card channel 1
TB3 Pin6 -> +5V Exe card channel 1
TB3 Pin 11 -> 0V Channel 2
TB3 Pin 14 -> +5V Channel 2
channel 3 same setup.
This seems to work so far, no crash since 30 minutes
EDIT: when i unplug the 5v psu the pc crashes sometimes too, thatś new...
EDIT 2: connected one scale...worked fine for 30 Minutes
connected another one, worked fine for 15 minutes.
wanted to edit this post to report good progress and booom crash
So all electrical components are run from one multi socket thingy. the only extra ground run is the one from the 24v PSU to the TB2 socket.
Last edit: 15 Jul 2020 17:19 by Onkelmat.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
15 Jul 2020 18:23 - 15 Jul 2020 18:52 #174765
by PCW
Replied by PCW on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
You might check to see if the 0V on the 5V, 24V or EXE units connect
to frame ground
Also I am assuming 5I25 W2 is on the down position (it should be)
And 7I77 W5 is on the right hand position (it should be)
Is the PC in the control case with the 7I77?
to frame ground
Also I am assuming 5I25 W2 is on the down position (it should be)
And 7I77 W5 is on the right hand position (it should be)
Is the PC in the control case with the 7I77?
Last edit: 15 Jul 2020 18:52 by PCW.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
15 Jul 2020 20:02 #174773
by Onkelmat
gonna check tomorrow if one of these connects to frame ground
W1 and W2 down
W5 is down if db25 is top
So I could verify today, that the 5v from the 7i77 to the EXE card doesn´t seem to be the Problem. When only 5v and GND/0V is connected to all three exe ports it´s running stable.
So only Ua0 Ua1 and Ua2 are left for causing me trouble.
Replied by Onkelmat on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
You might check to see if the 0V on the 5V, 24V or EXE units connect
to frame ground
Also I am assuming 5I25 W2 is on the down position (it should be)
And 7I77 W5 is on the right hand position (it should be)
Is the PC in the control case with the 7I77?
gonna check tomorrow if one of these connects to frame ground
W1 and W2 down
W5 is down if db25 is top
So I could verify today, that the 5v from the 7i77 to the EXE card doesn´t seem to be the Problem. When only 5v and GND/0V is connected to all three exe ports it´s running stable.
So only Ua0 Ua1 and Ua2 are left for causing me trouble.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
16 Jul 2020 18:28 #174875
by Onkelmat
Replied by Onkelmat on topic Retrofitting Maho MH600E 1989 - Meas 5i25 & 7i77
Today i´ve asked quite alot of people if they had an old PC with PCI slot.
Only one had an old pc that didn´t work anymore.
Dell Optiplex 830.
It has 4 PCI slots, what a beauty
The Nvidia graphics card has had blown elkos. i removed the card and hoped for the onboard graphics to be alive.
At first I had to get another Linux installation because the Pentium 4 HT was 32bit.
Short story the Maho is now running and back in it´s cozy corner in the shop.
I´ve tuned the axis a little more and it seems like the basic things work fine.
On/off
E-Stop
Coolant pump
Spindle left/right/stop
Toolchanger on/off
Jogging and no load gcode splash program
Homing (had to tweak the direction of the y axis)
I wanted to try some basic toolchange but somehow the vertical axis wants to crash my spindle into the worktable. How can i alter direction for "up"
Only one had an old pc that didn´t work anymore.
Dell Optiplex 830.
It has 4 PCI slots, what a beauty
The Nvidia graphics card has had blown elkos. i removed the card and hoped for the onboard graphics to be alive.
At first I had to get another Linux installation because the Pentium 4 HT was 32bit.
Short story the Maho is now running and back in it´s cozy corner in the shop.
I´ve tuned the axis a little more and it seems like the basic things work fine.
On/off
E-Stop
Coolant pump
Spindle left/right/stop
Toolchanger on/off
Jogging and no load gcode splash program
Homing (had to tweak the direction of the y axis)
I wanted to try some basic toolchange but somehow the vertical axis wants to crash my spindle into the worktable. How can i alter direction for "up"
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: cncbasher
Time to create page: 0.088 seconds